Did jesus forgive judas reddit As the OP rightly noted, in this pericope John clearly states that Jesus gave the bread to Judas (13:26), which is an act Jesus shares only with Judas, and then, moments later, Judas goes to betray Jesus. The false repentance of Judas was like that of Esau. And they all took Judas' side when Judas was saying that Mary of Bethany should have used the money she spent on the perfume for the poor rather than to use on Jesus, until Jesus told them what Mary did was honoring Him. He literally says this was fulfilled. ” And when he had dipped it, he gave it to Judas, son of Simon Iscariot. As I said before, Pilate decided to offer up Jesus as a potential candidate for the Governor's mercy, but the crowd was infiltrated by Pharisees who demanded the release of Barabbas, and the crucifixion of Jesus. I can forgive you, I cannot save you. We are no different when looking at both actions' baselines God sent Jesus so that all sins would be forgiven. r/BibleVerseCommentary A chip A close button A chip A close button We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Crypto All of our sins wound Jesus, but due to His pure love when we harm him, all that he shows us is love. You’ve got to be blind to think that. God knows. When someone says "If Christianity is real, why did {insert pastor's name here} do {insert sin here}? See hypocrites!" we can point to examples of where people who knew Jesus directly did some pretty bad stuff. 27:4) and take back what he did by returning the money. Can we be perfect? No. Matthew 26; But Jesus said to him, “Put your sword in its place, for all who take the sword will perish by the sword. If God can forgive Judas, then he can forgive any of us. Jesus is reaching out yet again, as he did when he washed Judas's feet, to convince his friend to turn back from his plan. ) So it isn't that far fetched to think the same occurred So did Judas. (Sure, he didn't get Jesus killed, but he DID deny Jesus after Jesus said he would, and it didn't register to him until after it was done. Jesus was even willing to forgive him but Judas instead of seeking forgiveness he fell into despair and hanged himself Both Judas and Peter betrayed Jesus that night. Satan likely told Judas it was for the greater good, which it was, but when he did it, God damned him. Meier agrees, noting that although we know very little about Judas, the scholarly consensus says that “Jesus chose him as one of the Twelve, and he handed over Jesus to the Jerusalem authorities, thus precipitating Jesus's execution. Paul persecuted Judas had long slain himself before Jesus prayed also. Jesus speaking to the Father from the Cross is consistent with the rest of the Gospels. true Jesus obviously loved Judas as much as the rest of His disciples, I’ve heard that Judas’ dry wit made Jesus laugh more than any other man. The scene where L is cleaning Light's feet, it's a reference to the bible when Jesus cleans Judas's feet, the point of that scene in the bible is that it's about forgiving your enemies. Jesus’ crucifixion is necessary, so if not Judas, than someone else would be needed to fulfill the prophecy. And they parted his raiment, and cast lots. Jesus called him "a devil" as well, saying it would have been better for Judas if he'd never been born. Both followed Jesus, both were trusted disciples (for the most part), both had the same teacher, both saw the same miracles, both betrayed Jesus. His suicide was a product of fear and other factors. There are two ways that are described that he did it, and some say that they are contradictory, but they are in fact plausible that it occurred in tempo with each other so that one person's eyewitness account could be different from John 13:26-27 NLT — Jesus responded, “It is the one to whom I give the bread I dip in the bowl. These are examples of jesus’ unconditional love and mercy for us. If God is all-knowing and all-powerful, did Judas have any real choice in betraying Jesus? Judas was deceived into betraying Jesus. They religious authorities were intelligent men of their time and part of the Jewish aristocracy. God wasn't the one who tempted Judas. Judas is probably the hardest person for Jesus to forgive in the world, but if He could forgive Judas, then surely He could forgive anyone else. to forgive the carrying out of a legal sentence of tens of thousands that were crucified It was always destined that Judas would betray Jesus. Persecute him, isn’t it logical to think that judas would be forgiven? Jesus asks our father to forgive those who put him on the cross, so wouldn’t he forgive the person who put him there? Yes, Judas committed suicide, and he went to hell, but it was because he did not believe in Jesus, but instead betrayed Him, resulting in His death. Criticism of the Emperor or of the Roman state could be considered treason. Peter repented, Judas did not. He felt repentant and tormented over his betrayal that instead of going to the lord and repenting with his confession to the lord, he instead let the demons torment him to the point of suicide and hung himself. Jesus treats Judas very respectfully, not pointing the finger in front of all 12 making a big scene (v. In knowing that, it was preordained. Later gospels falsely invented story of Judas betraying Jesus for money or under demonic possession. The question is why doing sacrifices at all, god is all powerful why can't he just forgive and be merciful as he is supposed to be instead of sacrificing himself (which wasn't a sacrifice because jesus resurrected after 3 days, a sacrifice is giving up something for a greater good and jesus or god didn't lose anything because he came back). Matthew 19:21-22 KJV — Jesus said unto him, If thou wilt be perfect, go and sell that thou hast, and give to the poor, and thou shalt have treasure in heaven: and come and follow me. It was the DEVIL. the all forgiving did not forgive Judas. We all have an element of Judas, in that we all wound Jesus through our sin. Felt remorse. So he put the man to the test, and the man failed miserably. Luke even goes so far as to have Jesus forgive his executioners from the cross. Forgiveness on the Cross: In Luke 23:34, Jesus prayed for forgiveness for those who crucified Him, saying: "Father, forgive them; for they know not what they do. Jesus literally told Judas it would have been better had he never been born. Dipping and sharing bread was a token of friendship in their culture. The Pharisees didn't need Judas to point the way they could have gotten to HIM one way or another, whether that fateful night or the next "plotting". The sheer unlikelihood of forgiveness, its being spoken from the Cross under the most impossible of circumstances, evokes our deepest objections not only to Judas’ forgiveness, but to our own. Scripture tells us there are vessels that are made for destruction. Freedom of speech did not exist. " If Judas didn't know Jesus was the Lord, he falls under this category. Plus, Judas had the PERFECT redemption arch just waiting for him kind of like Peter denying knowing Jesus and then repenting afterwards. So it's true both that God allowed it to happen even using those acts to fulfill His plan for salvation, but also true that it was a grievous and wicked thing that Judas did. Only God can forgive sins. At the end of season two, this was reversed. Um, no, pard, God did not script the events of Jesus' death. GameStop Moderna Pfizer Johnson & Johnson AstraZeneca Walgreens Best Buy Novavax SpaceX Tesla. He was literally born, bred, and lead in life to do what he did and it’s sickening. They clearly blasphemed the Holy Spirit when they witnessed an irrefutable miracle and assigned them to the devil. Mark had every motivation, even a need, to shift the blame for the crucifixion away from the Romans and onto Jewish authorities. Feb 24, 2021 · The Bible says, “But whoever blasphemes against the Holy Spirit never has forgiveness, but is guilty of an eternal sin” (Mark 3:29). Judas is condemned for failing to believe in Jesus for the forgiveness of sin and for betraying someone who showed him nothing but love. If free will was present God couldn't have known ( and please interject with logic I'm here to learn). Instead he committed suicide. Just because you would have to force events to be able to predict them doesn't mean that God has to force events to be able to predict them. But better for Judas himself. And the rulers also with them derided him, saying, He saved others; let him save himself, if he be Christ, the chosen of God. He did not forgive…. Did Jesus forgive, in his last words, those who persecuted him and crucified him? Yes. ) The verb to choose is a key word in Bible history. Mar 3, 2022 · Here we see Jesus condemning Judas, but considering that Judas travelled with Jesus for nearly three years, we know He also gave Judas ample opportunity for salvation and repentance. They all came around though (well, most - talk about how Judas still had a shot at salvation, how God can forgive even him), which gives us hope. God ensured that Judas would do what he did. His betrayal occurred for a reason. “The truth is we don't know why Judas did what he did,” notes Cargill. What's he missing here? Jesus says, "Forgive them for they know not what they do. Judas regretted his choice and killed himself out of sheer despair. Again, forgiveness without salvation is meaningless. Business, Economics, and Finance. And anyway, your point falls a bit flat because Peter did that exact same thing without even thinking of it, and not realizing until after he did it. Not better for the world, because Jesus needed to die on the cross. " To deliver Jesus, Judas had to fulfill his obligation under the diabolical covenant he made to deliver him. While other disciples at times made great professions of faith and loyalty (John 6:68; 11:16), Judas never did so and appears to have remained silent. Source: The Mystical City Judas betrayed Jesus but there is no biblical record he believed, or claimed Jesus' miracles were from the devil, like the Pharisees did. Judas did not betray Jesus as an act of evil. Judas wanted money, something temporary, and knew it was stupid but did it anyway. There were instances in where Judas shows his true character, as he steals from the disciples living If Judas goes to hell it is because of unrepenance. Infinity is up to the person in question. Judas was attempting to force Jesus to use His powers to fight & take over the Roman power. Judas was among that crowd. This passage can only make sense if it is saying Judas is in hell. Our Lady and Jesus prayed for Judas right until the end but ultimately there was no hope, he was too far gone. Going off CCC 2283, God can provide a means of repentance, and He did to Judas (and the other Apostles). Sorry. He had seen the miracles of Jesus and heard his teachings, and still betrays him for money. The past could not be changed, and Jesus was not there to forgive him because he was dead! Judas condemned himself! There was redemption for those who died before Christ did. Judas was the son of perdition, the son of destruction, and he lives in eternal destruction because of his great sin. Peter and Judas. But when they denied him, Judas still did not return to Jesus for forgiveness. The gospels place Judas in the position of one that was prophecied in the Old Testament to betray Jesus. So while the Pharisees did bear some responsibility in this affair, it was still the Roman Governor, acting on behalf of the Roman The crowds (who literally worshipped Jesus 5 days before when he walked into Jerusalem) were caught up in the mob mentality of the moment and rather than having courage to go against the grain, not only did they play along but they added to the situation, hurling insults and blows upon Jesus. Judas was even in the room where they judged Jesus, and he told the leaders he regressed selling him out. jfuiis pghh tbrjqp vwtytr jrxcz lfx xacg nghj xnziw tcfazd zfkj ocyo gjt jycpy xud