How did judas die contradiction Verses Judas committed suicide by hanging Matthew 27:5 View context. com/2023/10/03/how-did-judas-die/ Similarly, the accounts of Judas’ death do not contradict one another when they are read as two accounts that work together to make for a fuller picture. Judas died by hanging himself. Acts 1:18 - And falling headlong, he burst asunder in the midst, and all of his Hence, no contradiction exists between Matthew’s gospel and Acts regarding the owner of this purchased field. How did Judas really die? Do the two different versions mean the Bible is inaccurate? A. Whereas Peter's words (recorded by Luke) mentions Judas's death (falling headlong, he burst asunder in the midst, and all his bowels gushed out) & buying of the field (Judas bought the field) in a different manner. ~~IF YOU WANT TO CONNECT~~LIKE GodLogic on Facebook:https://www. Judas did, indeed, hang himself out of guilt and shame. 27:3) is not the one normally used for repentance. Otherwise, if forced to acknowledge the two obviously different accounts in Matthew’s Gospel and Acts of the Apostles, the first step should be to “salami-slice” off the disposition of the reward money—did Judas throw the money back in the temple or did he buy land with it—so that there is only one major contradiction Judas did not die by hanging, but lived on, having been cut down before he was suffocated. " 1 Corinthians 15:5 And that he was seen of Cephas, then of the twelve. Falling Jan 23, 2025 · Before we explore biblical contradictions, we must first define what we mean by the term "contradiction. Matthew tells us that Judas died by hanging (death is inferred from the passage). Bible commentator Albert Barnes says the statement about Judas in Acts 1:18 didn't mean he had made a contract and paid for the land: "Now this man acquired a field with the price of his wickedness. Feb 10, 2025 · In the Christian New Testament we get two differing accounts on how Judas dies, we then get two different accounts on how the "Field of Blood" came to be. Theory 1: Some Bible scholars say the accounts don’t conflict but are two events occurring in Feb 2, 2024 · Q. So we know for certain that he hanged himself, but he would not have remained there very long due to the law given by God in Deuteronomy: Matthew 27:5 records: “So Judas threw the silver coins into the temple and left. In Acts, Judas is described as “falling headlong he burst open in the middle and all his bowels gushed out”. " Luke explains what happened later, after Judas' body began to decompose. The second objection I can raise is that if Judas fell headfirst like Acts tells us, then he could not have fallen that way if he hanged himself! Nov 19, 2021 · Judas Iscariot is well-known for betraying Jesus in exchange for 30 pieces of silver. There is no contradiction between these two accounts. Judas did not hang himself, but died another way Acts 1:18 View context. Why did these two authors choose to emphasize different aspects of Judas’ death? The Death of Judas - Early in the morning all the chief priests and the leaders of the people decided to execute Jesus. 2. He probably thought Jesus was going to wipe the Romans off the face of the Earth, or at least give them a stern talking to. The following is an example of contradiction: 1. Matthew 27:4-5 - 4 "Saying, I have sinned in that I have betrayed the innocent blood. The basic agreements between them are strong. Acts 1 is a description of what happened AFTER Judas hanged himself. Did Judas die by hanging himself, or by falling over in a field and having his midsection burst open spilling his guts everywhere? A. Judas died a miserable death. John also suggests financial dishonesty could have been a factor. Judas was a lot closer to Jesus than any of the others. wordpress. According to Matthew 27:3–10, Judas felt remorse after seei Sep 27, 2019 · Join us at: http://www. com. Acts 6:7), they may have given further details on Judas’s death that were later incorporated into the Gospel accounts. com/MuftiUthman Oct 31, 2024 · The Gospels differ in their portrayal of Judas’s motives. Matthew 27:5 talks about how Judas died after not wanting to repent for what he did, so he did die by killings himself. The gospel writers were not fond of Judas. any further reflection on his death would have distracted from the point of the story, which is Jesus and the early church. So we know for certain that he hanged himself, but he would not have remained there very long due to the law given by God in Deuteronomy: Dec 2, 2008 · A contradiction occurs when one statement excludes the possibility of another. Judas did hang himself, and either the rope, or the tree limb, broke in the process, and Judas fell onto the craggy rocks below. Is there a contradiction? No, of course not. He brought the 30 silver coins back to the chief priests and leaders. Apr 19, 2019 · Judas hanged himself first and then fell on the ground causing his body to burst open. com/godlogicgl/EMAIL: GodLo Jul 3, 2018 · As for the Judas accounts, both appear to offer an explanation as to HOW Judas died; that is, they both convey the fact that Judas died, and they give details of a life-ending event. How is that possible? There is, in fact, a good answer. What did he do with the money? HUMANIST SUPPOSED CONTADICTION: Concerning the death of Judas, the disloyal disciple, Matthew 27:5 states he took the money he had received for betraying Jesus, threw it down in the temple, and “went and hanged himself. ” They are out with their first volume: How Did Judas Die? And let me tell you, I am underwhelmed. There's no contradiction in these scriptures. ” On an initial reading, questions can arise about how exactly Judas died. Yes, friends, a little extrapolation, a little common sense, goes a long way. youtube. Matthew says that the field where Judas did not die (for it had yet to be purchased by the chief priests) was used for the burial of aliens. Aug 17, 2021 · Judas's death and who bought the field, both differ; Matthew records Judas hanged himself and the Chief Priests bought the field. As mentioned above, a body falling from a tree will not likely “burst open. Oct 11, 2024 · Contradictions Surrounding Judas' Death. How do you reconcile this? Surely if bible is word of God there must be only one version! A man can't die twice !! Matthew 27:5 - Hanged himself. It may come as a surprise to learn that he died in two different ways in the Bible--and the stories are peppered with other contradictions too. Matthew records his initial suicide. In any case Judas was the Did Judas Iscariot die by hanging (Matthew 27:5) or did he die by falling and bursting open (Acts 1:18)? This if often a question in the bible most people as How did Judas really die? There appear to be 2 accounts in the Bible. Mar 10, 2010 · When Peter spoke before the other apostles, it might have already been understood by all that Judas had already died. The only thing he's mistaken about is that in Acts, Judas "dies accidentally. In Matthew, it says that he hanged himself: Matthew 27:5 And he cast down the pieces of silver into the sanctuary, and departed; and he went away and hanged himself. ” (NLT) Acts 1:18 – “Judas had bought a field with the money he received for his treachery. But the money was Judas’s—so legally Judas purchased the field and Matthew’s version is correct. patreon. I just want to point out that this was an entirely serious post. The Second Law of Logic, the Law of Non-Contradiction, (LNC) says that something cannot be both true and false at the same time and in the same sense. It is not a contradiction to describe something differently: Judas was hung and Judas fell down. And he [Judas] cast down the pieces of silver in the temple, and departed, and went and hanged himself. Mar 17, 2021 · “Contradiction” 7: How Did Judas Die? Objection: Matthew 27:5 Judas dies by hanging himself; Acts 1:18 Judas dies because he jumped off a cliff Answer: No, he fell off the cliff after he hung himself. com/add/valorthodoxia#christian #jesus #islam #bib Nov 30, 2008 · Like Peter, Judas is remorseful after the fact, changing his mind about the wisdom of his deed after seeing Jesus condemned (Matt. com/valorthodoxiahttps://twitter. There are two important principles to keep in mind when investigating alleged Bible contradictions. org Feb 10, 2020 · If they didn’t rush through their daily devotional, they’d catch some obvious contradictions. Judas died by hanging and then his lifeless body fell from the noose (probably because of an earthquake). Since the word for blood (Matt 27:8; Acts 1:19) is practically the only piece of shared vocabulary, the two accounts are clearly not based on any common written source. (2) How did Judas die? In the Gospel of Matthew, Judas is described as hanging himself after throwing the silver in the temple. ” Judas’ body must have been hanging from a tree, and he began to rot. Even though the details can be reconciled, it is important to understand that Matthew is interested in showing that Judas’s betrayal fulfills prophecy (27:9-10). PATREONhttps://www. The truth of the matter is, however, like the accounts of Jesus’ resurrection (and many other Bible events) these two verses simply supplement each Jun 8, 2020 · Assuming then that Judas was a real person who in some sense “betrayed” Jesus, is a suicide or other violent or unnatural death well-attested, such that we can eliminate the possibility that the guy just simply got on with his life and perhaps breathed a sigh of relief at getting out of a cult (assuming he could even think in terms of a cult– clearly, he must have found something wrong But Acts 1:18-19 seems to say its name came from its being the place where Judas died. Instead they draw upon word of mouth testimony from participants in the original events. The New Testament provides two accounts of his death: Matthew's direct narrative and Luke's record of Peter's description in Acts. Matthew 27:5 correctly recorded Judas’ manner and cause of death as suicide by hanging. snapchat. May 25, 2009 · There is no contradiction surrounding Judas’ death but rather two descriptions given by two different authors of the same event. Le Matthew 27:3-8 Then Judas, which had betrayed him, when he saw that he was condemned, repented himself, and brought again the thirty pieces of silver… What Did Judas Really Do With The Money? Judas was paid 30 pieces of silver to betray Jesus. Unlike Peter, Judas does not feel the “godly grief” of repentance (2 Cor. How did Judas die? That's easy. Then Judas, who had betrayed Jesus, regretted what had happened when he saw that Jesus was condemned. 30 pieces of silver is about 100 bucks in todays money. There is no contradiction about Judas’ death only two descriptions given by two different writers from two different perspectives. Papias’ description of Judas’ death can be illuminated by comparison with ancient biographical and medical literature, in which oedema and parasitic infections are a consequence of greed, and also apocalyptic texts, in which worms become an emblematic form of divine This article critically analyzes contradictions within biblical texts regarding Judas' use of the betrayal money and the details of his death. He did not die a miserable death. 20:10). In Acts, Judas is identified as acquiring the field with “the rewards of his wickedness”. How did Judas die? Did he hang himself or did he fall and burst? This article examines the differences between Matthew and Acts and argues that there is no contradiction, but a possible text corruption in Acts. " Mar 26, 2019 · This one may be a little icky but there seems to be two different accounts of Judas dying. To paraphrase in slang English, "Judas sure did 'purchase' a piece of landthe 'burial plot' his dead body fell on. nmkna dyjgkv aqate gjpjxo lni rdjkr ivzx soahvz mwhk nmcr kxtszfi aqh zolbrho kzvc hkxim