Carcassonne vs cascadia reddit Updated Apr 20, 2024. Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now Cascadia vs Splendor: A Comparison of These Two Board Games - Game Night Mastery Carcassonne vs 7 The #1 Reddit source for news, information, and discussion about modern board games and board game culture. Apr 20, 2024 · The Best Games Like Carcassonne. Cascadia is one of these "Spiel des Jahres" with staying power, like Azul. Cascadia is more about building out your cascadia biome. It doesn't eliminate the fact that a series of lucky draws will help you out - but it does give all of your opponents a chance to leverage anything you've got coming down the pipe, greatly mitigating the potential advantage you get from it. However, if I put this or Carcassonne on the table in front of less experienced players, most people will actually be interested in playing Cascadia. The puzzle is more dynamic in Cascadia and feels more fresh on repeat plays. Cascadia > Calico but both are good. We got Cascadia during the B&N sale and we are a bit addicted. Aug 2, 2021 · Honestly, if this is all that Cascadia was, it would be pretty good. The first two have good interaction that changes games up with subsequent plays. The game would need to work for 2 players. Carcassonne is a tile-laying game where players collectively construct the area around the medieval French city of Carcassonne while competing to place followers on various I mean you can go do a poll, Cascadia vs samurai. There’s some nice overlaying of different types of puzzles that aid in that and Cascadia has a couple extra systems that take it to the next level. I think they’re great games and good fun for non-gamers too. Carcassonne appears innocent and friendly, but winds up being incredibly passive aggressive, once you know how to play. ). -Play time. There’s a reason why cascadia is selling well. Yep! It is co-designed by @rf_seattle, @urbanfots, @Melvinrobb, and myself (Shawn)! We're all part of the original Cascadia development team so we took some of the original development brainstorms and some new ideas and built the expansion together. Cascadia definitely has a little bit of novelty/hype at the moment for us, but we've played both a similar number of times. I find Cascadia is slightly easier to teach, but they are both really easy to learn. Land vs Sea is a really crunchy take on Carcassonne, designed from the ground up for 2p, with a team option for 4p, and an interesting asymmetrical option for 3p. Aug 2, 2021 · Category: Tile-placement gameDesigner: Randy FlynnPublisher: Flatout GamesYear Published: 2021Players: 1-4Playing Time: 30 - 60 minsTo Play or Not To Play: PlayFlatout Games is best known for their 2020 hit game Calico. I like all of these qualities and own the following games which share most of these qualities: Calico, Azul: Summer Pavilion, Patchwork, Kingdomino, Sagrada and Carcassonne Aug 14, 2022 · Un peu délaissés, les jeux de placement de tuiles reviennent en force avec nos deux jeux de société de la semaine, Akropolis et Cascadia. Carcassonne is the simplest and probably the one I would recommend, it is a great game to have in every collection, is easy to explain, has 0 setup time, and you can add expansions if you want a little more to think about. The anniversary isn't compatible with the expansions. Please see the Rules-page for a full list of the rules. I do like the fact that Parks highlights a ton of actual national parks with great artwork vs. Cascadia is a newer game with beautiful artwork and easy-to-learn gameplay, while Carcassonne is a classic game with a medieval theme and a variety of expansions. Subreddit Rules: 1 I have both Cascadia and Calico. Cascadia's challenge is getting the animals in the correct scoring patterns, with actual tile placement feeling much less important. Splendor is a solid choice. While the complexity and game length are on par, the mechanics and play have almost nothing in The #1 Reddit source for news, information, and discussion about modern board games and board game culture. This game looks reminiscent of Carcassonne. I like and have kept Cascadia specifically because it's a chill tile laying, build your little map, with a pleasant amount of puzzle to maximize points, that plays quickly, and has some decent variety. Do I have A good example of new school vs old school might be something like modern art (1992) vs ark nova (2021). Playing time for Cascadia for a 3-4p games seems to consistently be around the 40-45 I've a friend within the same age range as your parents, entries in her own collection include titles like Carcassonne, Photosynthesis, Sagrada, Calico, and Isle of Cats. Posted by u/GameNightMaster - 1 vote and no comments Spirit Island vs Robinson Crusoe: A Comparison of Two Popular Cooperative Board Games - Game Night Mastery upvote r/GameNightMastery Posted by u/GameNightMaster - 1 vote and no comments Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now Cascadia vs Splendor: A Comparison of These Two Board Games - Game Night Mastery Carcassonne vs 7 I haven’t played Azul but I have played both Splendor and Cascadia. Wingspan and Cascadia are the ones that are scientifically accurate (Everdell has animals with clothes, for example). If you want games that are easy to teach non-hobbyists and that have a lot of replay value, then there are quite a few that can be suggested. The popular gateway games: Carcassonne, Azul, Ticket to Ride, Ethnos, Blue Lagoon and Mission Red Planet. Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. Looking at the rest of your list, I'm not sure I would recommend this one. So I’ll have to wait for another time. From reviews people found this version to be a better option over vanilla carcassonne. I'm looking for games that are similar since it seems we are both heavily drawn to this type of game. Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now Cascadia vs Splendor: A Comparison of These Two Board Games - Game Night Mastery Carcassonne vs 7 Fully admit I bought the game on the strength of the art lol. No one points at Carcassonne and goes, “Ooh. I don’t find it highly competitive, or at least not as competitive as trying to sneak a big Meeple onto other players features. Sounds like you have your answer, but yeah most board games could be deemed to be a toy ("children's product") and toys intended for kids under 14 have certain safety limitations and anything for kids under 12 has to undergo testing (choking, flammability, small parts, sharp edges, mechanical and chemical testing, etc. See Also: Posting Guidelines; Community Guidelines; Off-Topic Subjects Feb 16, 2024 · Cascadia and Carcassonne are both popular tile-laying board games with distinct differences. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. I had Cascadia on order for Christmas but unfortunately my order was cancelled and I couldn’t source another copy (in English!) on time. Eh, I think Catan vs TTR isn't really a fair comparison either, don't get me wrong, Carcassonne beats them both for sure, but Catan also has a huge variety in starting setups, both with the resoruces and then where players make their first settlements, and there's plenty of negotiation/social interaction as well. Cascadia having a little more general “outdoors” feel to it. 1) and Traders & Builders (exp. *while Carcassonne remains a staple in this category, Kingdomino and Calico rather than Cascadia are by far my most played of the newer tile laying gateways. Sagrada, Cascadia (tile laying game that is a better version of Carcassonne), Quacks of Quidlinburg (push your luck bag building game), Ethnos (I think recently reprinted as Archeos Society) a set collecting area control game, the Quest for El Dorado (deck building racing game), Camel Up (betting game), Ra (auction game), Nidaviller (another As a contrasting example: Carcassonne. It doesnt really need house rules, but you could play around with the number of tiles during setup (more tiles at lower player count for longer games, less tiles with impatient small kids). I think the results would speak for themselves - do you genuinely believe samurai would be more popular? Im just going by my experience plus the online sentiment. This is over games like Carcassonne (bit to bland, over played) and Calico (bit too much brain burn puzzle) etc. Stick with the standard. It stormed up the BoardGameGeek rankings, and Mar 27, 2022 · I personally love both. Cascadia is more relaxing to me than Carcassonne. 7), and more player interaction (modern art is a 3-5 player action while ark nova can play solo and gives players the option I find that playing as a couple co-operative board games work a bit better, it gets boring after a while to play competitive but it might be only me, so for that I reccomend Pandemic, it's a classic, has a bit of a set up time but it's a really good game, there are many many themes for it and you can just get whatever appeals to you. But I don't think Cascadia… Finally, the wonderful production and price point puts Cascadia in a league of its own as a gateway game. But Cascadia comes with four different variations for each animal card! The #1 Reddit source for news, information, and discussion about modern board games and board game culture. Agricola vs Carcassonne: A Comparison of Two Popular Board Games - Game Night Mastery Small World vs Takenoko: A Comparison of Two Popular Board Games - Game Night Mastery Cascadia is a step of difficulty above the other 3 you mentioned. 2) is a great way to elevate the complexity as the kids get better. It has Is Cascadia Like Catan? A Comparison of Two Popular Board Games - Game Night Mastery Another has suggested you try the three tile hand - but I'll also suggest you try two tile open hand. Carcassonne has persisted as one of the greatest tile-placement games for decades thanks to its fairly simple rules but challenging strategy, and Cascadia is simultaneously simpler and more challenging. -Teaching. Join the community and come discuss games like Codenames, Wingspan, Brass, and all your other favorite games! Welcome to the Carcassonne reddit community! Whether you're new to the game, an experienced tile-layer, or simply visiting, all are welcome who enjoy this amazing game. g. Then again, she's an old school nerd who used to play D&D and MtG so mileage may vary. Quand on évoque les jeux de placement de tuiles, on Welcome to the Carcassonne reddit community! Whether you're new to the game, an experienced tile-layer, or simply visiting, all are welcome who enjoy this amazing game. Cascadia focuses on creating a balanced ecosystem, while Carcassonne is about building a medieval city. Propelled by a successful Kickstarter, Calico gained a reputation as a welcoming, family-friendly game with tons of hidden depth. I felt Kingdomino got a little samey after a bit. Get expansion 1 immediately, and keep expansion 2 in mind. I'm primarily all about heavy complex stuff, but named Cascadia my number 2 of the year. Haven't played carcassonne but we got the south seas version. I just found although it's not new or inventive it perfectly threads the eye of the needle of easy teach and understanding to non-gamers, but enough puzzle that it will engage experienced board games. In Cascadia, if your observant of the other players tableau you may be able to “steal” a tile they may have chosen on their turn. Join our community! Come discuss games like Codenames, Arkham Horror, Terra Mystica, and all your other favorite games! Rules. However, aside from the fact that both games have broad appeal, I do not think there is any reason to predict people who like Catan will like Carcassonne. Teach me this one!” I love light tile laying games so there is room in my heart and shelf for Carcassonne and Cascadia (and Azul and Sagrada and Agricola vs Carcassonne: A Comparison of Two Popular Board Games - Game Night Mastery The #1 Reddit source for news, information, and discussion about modern board games and board game culture. Any help would be appreciated. It's probably the other most-recommended "gateway" game. We've taken to calling games like Azul, Cascadia, Calico, etc "take and make" games. Related. Player interaction is part of what gives Carcassonne its longevity. In response to if the expansion is designed by Randy Flynn: . For replayability, I'd say it's Carcassonne & El Dorado ahead of Kingdomino. It seemed like everyone was just kind of doing their own thing to score. 3 vs 3. Kingdomino is very underrated I feel, especially at two players, or when playing 7x7 with four players using two sets of tiles. With Cascadia you also have almost zero player interaction. There are also auction games like Modern Art, Medici and Ra. For my tastes Carcassonne isn't Carcassonne without Inns & Cathedrals (exp. Cascadia, Patchwork, Calico, Isle of Cats, NY Zoo, etc. Join the community and come discuss games like Codenames, Wingspan, Brass, and all your other favorite games! Agricola vs Carcassonne: A Comparison of Two Popular Board Games - Game Night Mastery Yes, Azul and Cascadia are both Abstract strategy, Family-style, light, beautiful, open drafting, pattern building, tile placement games with end gaming bonuses. Join the community and come discuss games like Codenames, Wingspan, Brass, and all your other favorite games! In the past several years, a number of light tile layers have gotten a lot of positive reviews and sales (e. But in the 90s Settlers of Catan and Carcassonne were the start of a major revolution in board game design and market. Follow Followed Like Link copied to clipboard. The #1 Reddit source for news, information, and discussion about modern board games and board game culture. Old school euros typically have shorter playtimes (45 min vs 2+ hours), less complicated rules (Bgg weight 2. That is a lot of fun and points are tallied as you play as it's more gather resources and trade them for points. Or check it out in the app stores Cascadia vs Carcassonne: A Comparison of Two Popular Board Games But give Cascadia 10 more plays and you’ll probably find it becomes pretty “same-y” also. Join the community and come discuss games like Codenames, Wingspan, Brass, and all your other favorite games! I’ve played Cascadia over 100 times and Calico around 25. Spirit Island vs Robinson Crusoe: A Comparison of Two Popular Cooperative Board Games - Game Night Mastery upvote r/GameNightMastery No doubt Carcassonne is an evergreen classic. The Best Games Like Ticket To Ride . Wingspan has a lot of bird facts on each card with accurate illustrations of the birds. Some people can struggle with the farmers scoring in Carcassonne, but you can play without them if you want (I did this when teaching my 5yo). Join the community and come discuss games like Codenames, Wingspan, Brass, and all your other favorite games! Both also have expansions available and the setup and card variety allow for each game to be a little unique. I personally prefer Azul, TTR, and Quacks of Quedlinburg, but Cascadia is the best game in my entire collection for getting people interested in the hobby. I also enjoy Cascadia and its similar games. We did try patchwork, and weren' Not Everdell. Your personal preferences and play style should be considered when choosing between the two games. I see them compared like this often but they play like completely different games. Cascadia is terrific depending what you're looking for. I enjoy Carcassonne, even as a solitaire game vs AIs. Personally I prefer Wingspan (despite living in Cascadia). Really the tile drafting is the only bit that is the same. ) and third-party certification, otherwise it should to be labeled 12+ only. Apr 6, 2025 · The #1 reddit source for news, information, and discussion about modern board games. 26 votes, 92 comments. By John Reece Alexander. Carcassonne is a tile-laying game where players collectively construct the area around the medieval French city of Carcassonne while competing to place followers on various features and score the most points. I am wondering, is Carcassonne the base game still worth buying and playing today? I played it once a couple of years ago, and I didn't quite see how i could hinder the other person while benefiting myself. Have any of you been to Carcassonne in France? Is it worth going out of my way to visit there while in Europe? I do like exploring old cities and castles in addition to my love for the game, is there anything else worth going there for beyond a day trip? We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. I've been looking through the sub reddit to find games similar-ish to the game but haven't really felt there have been any listed (ticket to ride and catan were but she does not like these games) does anyone have any recommendations based on her love for art design and quick to pick up rules (she doesn't like the art design of carcassonne) FWIW, while Cascadia is a "tile-laying" it's significantly different from Carcassonne by virtue of the play area being a shared space in Carcassonne which completely changed the nature of interactivity and strategy. Dec 31, 2023 · Cascadia and Carcassonne are two popular tile-laying board games that offer a strategic and engaging experience. I personally enjoy the Hunters and Gatherers version. I didn’t even read what it was about haha 😅 The mechanics are juuust unforgiving enough to make the game interesting and give weight to your choices, but not so much that you feel like it’s too hard. vjvpzmplgapqbkuvlwaxfkuesfanvghdazakiuxkbuspdsbpemjwsohwjqbwplonufloaldoa